The Impact of Different Types of Teaching Videos on Learning Satisfaction and Cognitive Load
Tan Shaojie1, Arshad Abd Samad2.
The development of information technology provides a variety
of ways for humans to acquire knowledge. Among the more common
information technology used in teaching and learning is the video. This
research explores the concept of teaching videos of declarative knowledge
and the influence of different types of teaching videos on learners’ learning
satisfaction and cognitive load. It first sorts out the related research
of instructional videos through literature research, and attempts to
comprehensively consider the manpower, material resources, and technical
difficulties invested in the production process of several common types of
instructional videos summarized through literature research. They are
classified into three categories, namely low cost, medium cost and high cost.
Then, the impacts of three common but different types of teaching videos with
different production processes on the learning effect of learners are studied.
The study is in an experimental environment, with college students as the
research object, strictly controlling the number and time of video viewing
by learners, first pre-testing the subjects, and then letting the subjects learn
the video followed by a post-test. The data analysis results show that in an
experimental environment, the impact of three different types of instructional
videos – i.e. PPT screen recording, picture-in-picture fusion and studio
recording - on the retention test, transfer test and cognitive load of learners
had no significant difference. However, in terms of learning satisfaction, the
studio camera group has the highest learning satisfaction, while the PPT
screen recording group has the lowest, with the studio camera group having
a significantly higher score than the PPT recording group. F(2,68)=3.267,
P=0.044. Based on these findings, this article provides a reference for the design and development of future declarative knowledge instructional
videos from the level of instructional video resource construction, so that
instructional video designers and developers will discuss how to ensure
the learning effect while better reducing the teaching in the process of
making the video. At the same time, due to the limitation of research time,
this research still has some shortcomings, which requires more rigorous
and comprehensive argumentation in the future.
Affiliation:
- Anhui International Studies University, China, China
- Taylor University , Malaysia
Toggle translation
Download this article (This article has been downloaded 45 time(s))