Traumatic gallbladder perforation is an unusual but potentially life-threatening injury that can occur following blunt or penetrating abdominal trauma. A 46-year-old male presented to the emergency department following a motor vehicle accident (MVA). He complained of severe abdominal pain and sustained ecchymosis with localized tenderness over the right upper quadrant. Despite a positive focused assessment with sonography in trauma scan, initial computed tomography of the abdomen revealed grade 1 liver and splenic injury but was unable to identify gallbladder perforation. He was initially managed conservatively until he developed secondary signs of sepsis after 24 hours. An exploratory laparotomy revealed a perforated gallbladder. A subtotal cholecystectomy was done. A retrospective review revealed a missed gallbladder perforation from an earlier CT scan assessment. We report a case of missed gallbladder perforation following MVA which was only diagnosed intraoperatively after failing non-operative management, following which the patient underwent laparotomy and subtotal cholecystectomy.